My 2 love these treats. I have used them for years and always great. If you are worried about sharp edges, simply break them into smaller pieces. They are crispy like potato chips.

My dog Jeni loves these dog treats. She's an all organic doggie so these are a nice variety to add to her healthy regimen. I also like the fact that it is liver. She unfortunately doesn't eat much of that.

My dog Jeni loves these! So healthy!

My rottweiler loves these and also the Beef and Bison Bites. This is her first thing in the morning treat while I have my coffee. I break the larger ones in half. As far as the small pieces in the bottom of the bag, I put those on a saucer and she cleans the plate so none are wasted.

Considering I read the reviews on this producd I did have a concern on the sharp edges. I really wanted to try it. This may be helpful! Yes I did have a concern on the bits actually having sharped edges so I decided to take one and crush it to powder form and then added couple of drops of water to moisten the little pile that came out. I reshaped it into a small ball or flatten shape and gave it to my dog since she's a senior dog and wanted no accidents of any choking. Try this it works! My dog loves it. Actually I enjoy it since I feel its safe to eat without sharp edges this way. That's comforting and a great nutritional treat.

Product has great ingredients. However, the bites have sharp edges which, when eaten or broken up can cause choking/injury hazard. I would like to see them remade in chunks rather than chips, which would be safer to feed.

My dogs, and all visiting dogs, absolutely love these. I love the 2-ingredient only formula. I don't love the price or the fact that the bottom of bag is all crumbs. Nevertheless, I'm giving it 4 stars